Edward Arnold as Daniel Webster Walter Huston as Mr. Scratch James Craig as Jabez Stone Anne Shirley as Mary Stone Jane Darwell as Ma Stone Simone Simon as Belle Gene Lockhart as Squire Slossum John Qualen as Miser Stevens H. B. Warner as Justice John Hathorne Alec Craig as Eli Higgins George Cleveland as Cy Bibber Lindy Wade as Daniel Stone Jeff Corey as Tom Sharp (uncredited) Carl Stockdale as Van Brooks (uncredited)